# Solved – Does rnorm produce numbers with replacement/without replacement

`rnorm` is an R language function defined as:

``rnorm.X generates multivariate normal random variates in the space X. ``

Consider `rnorm(1000, 50, 5)`, drawing 1000 values from a normal distribution with mean 50 and standard deviation 5.

Are these 1000 values iid? If they are then the sampling is done with replacement. Are `rnorm` and `runif` samples generated with replacement or without replacement?

Contents

Both the normal and uniform distributions are continuous; ie, any particular value has probability of zero. Obviously there is numerical precision and other considerations involved with a machine-specific implementation but for all intents and purposes, you can suppose that $$mathbb P(X = x) = 0$$ for any particular $$x$$; ie, the probability that you randomly draw a value identical to any particular point you specify is $$0$$. Further, if you have any countable (ie, you could count it out, possibly infinite) or finite (ie, you have a set with a fixed number of elements) set $$mathcal X$$, $$mathbb P(X in mathcal X) = 0$$ as well. That is, for any countable set of real numbers within the support of the distribution (for the uniform case, this would be $$[0, 1]$$, and for the normal case, the support is just all of the reals) there is also a probability of $$0$$ that a "new draw" or any finite number of draws will be equal to any of them (this applies for all continuous distributions; one can define mixed distributions in which this is NOT the case, but for continuous random variables, this is always the case as by definition a continuous distribution is defined over uncountably infinitely many points). There is no such thing as "with replacement" and "without replacement" if the distn function is continuous; further, if the distribution is discrete "without replacement" explicitly violates $$iid$$ (as you are specifically and deliberately omitting values from the possible sets of values based completely on the values you have already obtained). `rnorm` and `runif` generate $$iid$$ samples.